FunEmpire Australia Blog

10 Best Pizza Shop Sydney Has To Offer [2024]

Rachel Tan Profile Photo

Pizza Shop Sydney

Best Pizza Shops Sydney
Best Pizza Shops Sydney

Pizza doesn’t really need an introduction. This well-known meal is one of the most well-known all over the world. Pizza’s popularity has never waned till the present. Because of our busy schedules and fast-paced lifestyles, pizza may be eaten as a dinner or as a snack. You could eat a whole pizza box by yourself. Pizza, on the other hand, is a wonderful “get-together” food. With this in mind, you should be aware of the best pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

1. Capitano

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Full Bar Available, Indoor Seating, Vegetarian Friendly
Websitehttps://www.capitano.com.au/
Address421 Rathdowne St, Carlton VIC 3053, Australia
Phone+61 3 9134 8555
E-maileat@capitano.com.au
Operating Hours5:30PM – 9:30PM Wednesdays – Thursdays | 5:30PM – 10PM Fridays | 12PM – 10PM Saturdays | 12PM – 9:30PM Sundays

This Italian eatery is the brainchild of the people behind nearby Bar Liberty. While the Italian-American cuisine at Capitano was influenced by the eateries in New York City, the restaurant itself is uniquely Melbourne. The crust of the sourdough pizza is thin, crunchy, elastic, and very nuanced. South Australian wheat is used to make the base. The wheat was fermented for a total of 48 hours, the final 12 of which were done at a low temperature, and then allowed to rest for six hours before being baked in an electric oven. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • The crust of the sourdough pizza is thin, crunchy, elastic, and very nuanced.
  • South Australian wheat is used to make the base.
  • The wheat was fermented for a total of 48 hours, the final 12 of which were done at a low temperature, and then allowed to rest for six hours before being baked in an electric oven.

Customer Testimonial:

“Delicious pizza and pasta, I’ve never been disappointed with a meal at Capitano and always look forward to my next visit.”

Jess Pizzol

2. DOC Pizza and Mozzarella Bar

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Breakfast, Takeaway Available, Full Bar Available, Outdoor Seating
Websitehttps://docgroup.net/
Address6 Riverside Quay, Southbank VIC 3006, Australia
Phone+61 3 9686 2780
Operating Hours5PM – 9PM Tuesdays, Sundays | 12PM – 9PM Wednesdays – Saturdays

D.O.C. refers to “authentic Italian cuisine,” a cooking style that incorporates both traditional and contemporary elements as a tribute to Italy’s rich culinary heritage. Nearby neighborhoods include Carlton, Southbank, Mornington, and Surry Hills, creating a tight metropolitan region. It’s normal to have to wait in line at DOC, but the friendly Italian staff will keep you company while you wait. The “Salsicca” pizza, for instance, is a product of the rapid evolution of thin-crust pizzas; it has a new combination of broccoli mash, mozzarella, and sausage. Making fresh, nutritious salads is not an afterthought. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • The “Salsicca” pizza, for instance, is a product of the rapid evolution of thin-crust pizzas; it has a new combination of broccoli mash, mozzarella, and sausage.
  • Making fresh, nutritious salads is not an afterthought.

Customer Testimonial:

“Great pizza. Very authentic.  Didn’t think much of the Chianti.  Waiter was good fun.”

Ewen Stewart

3. Kaprica

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Coffee and Tea, Puttanesca Pizza, Broccoli Pizza, Potato Pizza, Tomato Base, Gnocchi, Tiramisu
WebsiteFacebook
Address50 Grattan St, Carlton VIC 3053, Australia
Phone+61 447 043 404
Operating Hours4PM – 10PM Tuesdays – Sundays
Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Coffee and Tea, Puttanesca Pizza, Broccoli Pizza, Potato Pizza, Tomato Base, Gnocchi, Tiramisu

Those who are familiar with Kaprica and the pizza there may already understand what I’m referring to when I say that it’s commonly referred to as “Pietro’s pizza.” Additionally, it’s highly likely that they have already consumed it. The bases are made according to traditional Neapolitan recipes and are not altered in any way before being seasoned and baked per the customer’s specifications. They come with gnocchi, Melbourne’s most popular pasta dish, and a variety of Campari-flavored cocktails. To complement it, they offer a selection of campari-flavored drinks. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • The bases are made according to traditional Neapolitan recipes and are not altered in any way before being seasoned and baked per the customer’s specifications.
  • They come with gnocchi, Melbourne’s most popular pasta dish, and a variety of Campari-flavored cocktails.

Customer Testimonial:

“Good pizza and great service”

Mariana Penaforte

4. Leonardo’s Pizza Palace

Key ServicesPizza, Takeaway Available, Full Bar Available, Vegetarian Friendly
Websitehttps://leonardospizzapalace.com.au/
Address29 Grattan St, Carlton VIC 3053, Australia
Phone+61 3 9242 0666
E-mailhello@leonardospizzapalace.com.au
Operating Hours5PM – 10PM Mondays – Thursdays | 5PM – 1AM Fridays | 12PM – 1AM Saturdays | 12PM – 9PM Sundays

Just like its irreverent South Yarra sibling, Leonardo’s House of Love, Leonardo’s has a raucous, party atmosphere; however, the inside is more spaghetti western than Neapolitan puritan. Nothing has changed except that the New York-style pizzas are getting bigger and better as they add more cheese and cook the dough so that it’s spongy, chewy, and burned. Leave the ketogenic diet out of your plans today. There is an incredible quantity of bread available. Typical fare includes crostini as the go-to starter and pizza with a side of ranch sauce (to dip the dough into, naturally). This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Raucous, party atmosphere
  • New York-style pizzas are getting bigger and better as they add more cheese and cook the dough so that it’s spongy, chewy, and burned.

Customer Testimonial:

“Unbelievable pizza. Lovely staff. Polenta also delightful. To be honest, I would go back for their ranch dipping suace alone!”

Zoe Hutchinson

5. 400 Gradi

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Mediterranean Food, Margherita, Italian Pizza, Bruschetta, Meatballs, Pastas, Full Bar Available, Indoor Seating
Websitehttps://400gradi.com.au/
Address99 Lygon St, Brunswick East VIC 3057, Australia
Phone+61 3 9380 2320
E-mailinfo@400gradi.com.au
Operating Hours12PM – 11PM Daily

Their story goes like this, according to them. Since their inception in 2008, 400 Gradi has called Brunswick’s central business district home. Like many Italian families, they’ve grown. They have locations all around the world, staffed by hardworking individuals who are committed to providing customers with a positive dining experience. You’d think 400 Degrees knows what they’re doing with pizza after winning so many World Pizza Championships. They certainly are. The bases, when cooked at 400 degrees, become chewy and puff up a little. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • 400 Gradi has called Brunswick’s central business district home.
  • They have locations all around the world, staffed by hardworking individuals who are committed to providing customers with a positive dining experience.
  • You’d think 400 Degrees knows what they’re doing with pizza after winning so many World Pizza Championships.
  • The bases, when cooked at 400 degrees, become chewy and puff up a little.

Customer Testimonial:

“The pizza and pasta are very delicious.”

Haubert Yauwenas

6. 48h Pizza e Gnocchi Bar

Key ServicesAuthentic Pizza and Pasta, Woodfire Pizza, Margherita Pizza, Prosciutto, Tiramisu, Vegan Options, Indoor Seating, Gluten Free Options, Vegetarian Friendly
Websitehttps://www.48h.com.au/
Address373 Malvern Rd, South Yarra VIC 3141, Australia
Phone+61 3 9824 2573
E-mailmarketing@48h.com.au
Operating Hours5PM – 9PM Tuesdays – Thursdays | 5PM – 10PM Fridays – Saturdays

A pizza that wins “Best Pizza in Australia” can only be exceptional. Both the Elsternwick and South Yarra locations of 48h Pizza e Gnocchi have been named by 50 Top Pizza as having the best pizza in Australia, with the former winning the title in 2019 and the latter in 2021 at the World Pizza Championships in Parma, Italy. The pizzeria acquired its name from the time it takes for the dough to rise when using all-natural ingredients, and as you would expect, they don’t cut corners anywhere. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Won “Best Pizza in Australia”
  • The pizzeria acquired its name from the time it takes for the dough to rise when using all-natural ingredients, and as you would expect, they don’t cut corners anywhere.

Customer Testimonial:

“Pizza & Pasta was great. Service excellent and food came out pretty quickly. Definitely will be back again.”

Schumi5

7. A25

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Pasta, Salads, Coffee, Vegetarian Friendly, Serves Cocktails, Vegan Options
Websitehttps://a25.com.au/
Address 720 Chapel St, South Yarra VIC 3141, Australia
Phone+61 3 9826 2233
Operating Hours11AM – 9:30PM Mondays – Thursdays | 11AM – 10PM Fridays – Saturdays | 11AM – 9PM Sundays

It’s impossible to refute the assertion that “pizza is tempting” made by the website A25. It seems that pizza is in the blood of the Nicolini family, since Remo’s brother Tony also manages a pizzeria. Remo Nicolini and his brother Tony Nicolini are involved in the hotel business as owners and operators of D.O.C. Remo makes his pizzas unique by utilizing unusual flours like kamut and spelt in the pizza crust. The toppings on the L.S.D. pizza are just as strange, like date cream, Italian sausage, and licorice dust. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • The Nicolini family’s involvement in the hotel business
  • Unusual flours like kamut and spelt as the pizza crust
  • The L.S.D. pizza has equally bizarre toppings, such as date cream, Italian sausage, and licorice dust.

Customer Testimonial:

“Very busy placeso book in advance. Had a takeaway with some vino to accompany the pizza, yum!”

Rodrigo Rubio

8. SPQR Pizzeria

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options
Websitehttps://www.spqrpizzeria.com/
Address26 Liverpool St, Melbourne VIC 3000, Australia
Phone+61 3 9671 3326
E-mailinfo@spqrpizzeria.com
Operating Hours5PM – 9PM Sundays – Tuesdays | 12PM – 2PM, 5PM – 9PM Wednesdays – Fridays | 5PM – 10PM Saturdays

S.P.Q.R. Pizzeria & Cucina is a chain of restaurants in New York City known for its sourdough Neapolitan-style pizza and traditional Italian fare, as well as its amazing music and street art. It’s time to face facts: pizza delivery by the slice is a major enabler. Four $5 pieces of pizza are placed on the kitchen pass at SPQR, like a lovely guilty conscience. If you order a Peroni with your $10 supper, you’ll save money. Just admit that you’ll always be a carb and cheese fiend, and tell yourself you’ll start the activated almond-paleo-superfood diet tomorrow. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Sourdough Neapolitan-style pizza
  • Traditional Italian fare
  • Music and street art
  • Pizza delivery by the slice

Customer Testimonial:

“Me and my friends had dinner on a Friday night the pizza was mazing, we had a great time. (loved the pepperoni pizza).”

Daniella Rossi

9. Compass Pizza

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options
Websitehttps://www.compasspizza.com.au/
Address319 Lygon St, Brunswick East VIC 3057, Australia
Phone+61 3 9387 6779
E-mailcompasspizza@gmail.com
Operating Hours5PM – 10PM Mondays – Saturdays | 5PM – 9:30PM Sundays

This darkly lit, rustic tavern and restaurant is the place to be if you’re in the mood for some excellent live music to accompany your craft beer and slice of pizza. The retro atmosphere and low prices at Compass Pizza make it a good choice for a fast takeaway dinner or a midweek supper on the way home from work, even if the restaurant hasn’t won any accolades. Vegan cheese and gluten-free bases are the only items that have been updated from the classic preparation of this dish. In other words, it’s quite standard fare. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Live music
  • Craft beer
  • Retro atmosphere
  • Low prices

Customer Testimonial:

“So this little gem is tucked away in Brunswick East. Dim litted, perfect for a casual cute dinners. Service was great and the food was even better, we got the mushroom pizza and it was absolutely amazing that we even came back again a week later! Definitely worth a try if you’re around the Brunswick area.”

Carmen Knight

10. +39 Pizzeria

Key ServicesItalian Cuisine, Pizza, Margherita, Italian Pizza, Margarita Pizza, Lasagna, Ravioli, Tiramisu, Full Bar Available, Gluten Free Options, Vegetarian Friendly
Websitehttps://www.plus39.com.au/
Address362 Little Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000, Australia
Phone+61 3 9642 0440
E-mailinfo@plus39.com.au
Operating Hours12PM – 3PM, 5PM – 9:30PM Mondays – Fridays | 12PM – 9:30PM Saturdays – Sundays

They began as a group of six friends who met over pizza and lasagna in Melbourne but whose hearts were in Naples. They frequently call home because they long for their nonna. They have talked on the phone for hours, swapping recipes, remembering the long nights, and gushing over Italy. +39 A pizzeria is a labor of love. This is a tribute to the pizzaiolo of Naples, the boys who ride Vespas through the narrow streets, and the Nonnas who beat their arses with wooden spoons before serving us steaming bowls of spaghetti. This is why you should know which are the top pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • A group of six friends who met over pizza and lasagna in Melbourne
  • Their hearts were in Naples
  • They frequently call home because they long for their nonna
  • +39 A pizzeria is a labor of love

Customer Testimonial:

“Came here on Friday night, so clearly they were crazily busy. But we got seated really quick, food came quick and was delicious the server was really patient and nice which must take efforts. Much appreciated.”

Charlotte Zhou

Pizza Shop Sydney

Overall, there are several reasons why pizza is still so popular today. Pizza has become so popular in modern culture that songs have been written about it. Every country has its own style of pizza, making it easier for customers to enjoy. Pizza, more than any other meal, has the power to unite people. We hope this helps you find the best pizza shop Sydney has to offer.

If you’re looking for more recommendations, you can check out our other posts below:

Rachel Tan - FunEmpire

Article by

Rachel Tan is the editor at FunEmpire Media Australia. She has over 8 years of experience in the media industry discovering the best local businesses, places and things to do in Australia. From lifestyle, entertainment, food, travel, education and more, Rachel is a trusted source to curate the very best Australia has to offer.