FunEmpire Australia Blog

10 Best Sandwich Shop Sydney Has To Offer [2024]

Rachel Tan Profile Photo

Sandwich Shop Sydney

Best Sandwich Shop Sydney
Best Sandwich Shop Sydney

Sandwiches have been around for over 2000 years, and it’s easy to see why these all-in-one alternatives are still a popular choice for a fast meal: they’re economical, portable, and available in a variety of varieties. Sandwiches combine bread, cheese, meats, veggies, and sauces to create some of our favorite meals. This makes it easy to adjust to customers’ tastes or to provide “build your own” options. This is why you should be aware of the best sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

1. Rusty’s Sandwich Parlour

Key ServicesCafe Food, Beet Reuben
Address189 Nicholson St, Brunswick East VIC 3057, Australia
Phone+61 3 9381 2005
Operating Hours9AM – 3PM Mondays – Fridays | 9AM – 2PM Saturdays – Sundays

If you’re in need of a fast, fulfilling meal and a good drink, then you should definitely check out this sandwich store and café. Both establishments provide comprehensive beverage lists guaranteed to quench any patron’s thirst. The eleven available sandwich selections include many that are suitable for vegetarians and vegans. The Beet Reuben is a delicious sandwich that everyone should try at least once, whether they are vegetarian or vegan. This sandwich is mostly made up of four things: pickled beets, fermented cabbage, vegan mozzarella, and Russian dressing. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Fully vegan sandwich options
  • Coffee and Sandwich Combos

Customer Testimonial:

“BEST SANDWICHES northside !!! Me and my friend went for the first time to try the infamous Rustys and we were incredibly impressed. The menu has great options for meat and veg and vegan eaters. The sandwiches were super fresh and soooo tasty. Also love the vibe of the workers and the packaging. 5/5 thank you!”

Laura Reid

2. Kelso’s Sandwich Shoppe

Key ServicesBurger, Sandwich, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian Friendly, Full Bar Available
Address271 Johnston St, Abbotsford VIC 3067, Australia
Phone+61 3 9495 6268
Operating Hours9AM – 3PM Wednesdays – Sundays

A simple café with a throwback vibe, Kelso’s serves coffee and pastries with a focus on making authentic sangas. The name of the business tells you all you need to know about it. A deluxe morning snack, which consists of two pieces of fluffy white bread packed with bacon, eggs, cheese, and tomato sauce, has the ability to change your life in significant ways. Mushrooms might be the star ingredient in vegetarian iterations of the famous breakfast food. This dish represents the classic morning meal that often includes mushrooms. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Open early for breakfast sandwiches
  • Serves other breakfast items like pancakes and eggs

Customer Testimonial:

“So good!!! I had the classic Kelso with avocado and it was amazing. The service was so friendly and the sandwich was super fresh and tasty. Will definitely be back!”

Anya A.

3.Heartattack and Vine

Key ServicesEuropean Style Neighborhood Bar, Chocolate, Wine, Drinks, Coffee, Breakfast, Takeaway Available, Wine And Beer
Address329 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053, Australia
Phone+61 3 9349 1891
Operating Hours8AM – 10:30PM Mondays – Thursdays | 8AM – 11PM Fridays – Saturdays | 8AM – 3PM Sundays

True to its European roots, Heartattack and Vine serves simple breakfasts, hearty lunches, and late-night drinks and snacks. Their nighttime menu centers on cicheti, a Venetian bar food style that is similar to tapas but has its own distinct dishes and flavors and is great for snacking, sharing, or a full meal. Heartattack is the kind of place where you can feel equally at home on a hot date, by yourself for a drink at the long bar, or while snacking for hours with friends at one of the communal tables. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Open late
  • Venetian bar food

Customer Testimonial:

The croissants here are made with some sort of delicious magic, coffees are excellent and good selection of sandwiches”

Daniel Nicholson

4. Rat the Cafe

Key ServicesCafe Food, Coffee and Tea, Breakfast, Takeaway Available, Brunch
Address72 Wales St, Thornbury VIC 3071, Australia
Operating Hours8AM – 3PM Mondays – Saturdays | 9AM – 2PM Sundays

Rat Coffee House is a local favorite. Organic fruits and vegetables, bread made with natural leavening, and free-range eggs are used whenever possible to make the restaurant’s brunch menu items. Brews of coffee, tea, and chocolate, as well as baked goods, are prepared by people who share the customers’ respect for provenance and craft. They utilize the one-of-a-kind assets they possess by employing both cutting-edge and conventional strategies. They use trash collection as a test bed for their experiments and make as much of their products as they can in-house. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Sells baked goods
  • Uses organic fruits and vegetables

Customer Testimonial:

“Staff are always delightful, coffee delicious, and their breakfast sandwich is beyond words. Thanks Rat cafe, see you soon :)”


5. The Catfish

Key ServicesBar Food, Full Bar Available, Nightlife, Live Music, Craft Beer
Address30 Gertrude St, Fitzroy VIC 3065, Australia
Phone+61 3 9417 6420
Operating Hours12PM – 11PM Sundays – Thursdays | 12PM – 1AM Fridays – Saturdays

On Gertrude Street in Fitzroy, tucked away from the hustle and bustle, you’ll find The Catfish, a blues-style tavern and one of Australia’s best sandwich shops. A winning sanga and a beverage are the only two things that can top each other. Their pizza steak and veggie cheesesteak are two interesting variations on the traditional sandwich. Sparrow’s Philly Cheesesteaks, Australia’s most famous steak restaurant, had its start at The Catfish, and that’s something we’re really proud of. They’ve been there for a while, but they’ve been providing great service to Catfish customers ever since they opened. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Proud of their history
  • Offers a variety of sandwiches

Customer Testimonial:

“Staff are well trained and provide exceptional service. Interaction between staff and regulars, and new customers create a great “local bar” feeling. Will definitely be back.”

Alexander Carruthers

6. Ima Project Cafe

Key ServicesJapanese Cuisine, Coffee and Tea, Japanese Breakfast, Pork Katsu, Miso Soup, Salmon
Address169 Elgin St, Carlton VIC 3053, Australia
Phone+61 3 9348 1118
Operating Hours7:30AM – 3PM Tuesdays – Fridays | 8AM – 3PM Saturdays – Sundays

I was wondering if you’ve ever tried a sandwich made in the Japanese fashion. Now is a good time to begin if you haven’t already done so. Located in a trendy part of Carlton, the Ima Project Cafe is renowned for its cutting-edge cuisine and unique preparation methods. The “ugly” vegetables that customers at the grocery store are unwilling to buy are transformed into delicious dishes like porridge, salads with soba noodles, and sandwiches. Because of this one thing, they are easy to tell apart from the rest of the pack. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Uses “ugly” vegetables
  • Unique preparation methods

Customer Testimonial:

“I like everything on this Japanese cafe. Cozy place and well organized. It’s feel like in Kyoto. Lovely place.”

Wander Wider

7. Falco Bakery

Key ServicesLocally Sourced Ingredients and Coffee, Bakery, Café Food, Coffee and Tea, Breakfast, Takeaway Available, Vegetarian Friendly
Address288 Smith St, Collingwood VIC 3066, Australia
Operating Hours8AM – 3PM Daily

The inspiration for starting Falco was to show the people of Collingwood that traditional baking techniques could be updated to meet the needs of today. Organic flour comes from New South Wales’s Wholegrain Milling; organic chocolate and cheese come from Australia’s Hunted & Gathered and Birdsnake; and organic milk comes from California’s Schulz Organic Dairy. The standard ingredients, such as eggs and salad or ham and cheese, are piled high until the bread is bursting. Collingwood’s Stella Coffee has a master roaster in the form of Tim Varney. baked using local ingredients by local bakers for local gourmets. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Uses local ingredients
  • Baked using organic flour

Customer Testimonial:

“Best chicken sandwich in town! So simple, but every component is done well and the bread is divine. Coffee is also great! Love stopping by here to grab a sandwich.”


8. Frankie’s Tortas and Tacos

Key ServicesMexican Cuisine, Takeaway Available, Outdoor Seating, Vegetarian Friendly
Address384 Smith St, Collingwood VIC 3066, Australia
Phone+61 447 239 656
Operating Hours10AM – 3PM Tuesdays – Saturdays | 11AM – 3PM Sundays – Mondays

We have taught you how to prepare sandwiches in the Japanese, Italian, and Spanish styles, but what about the Mexican method? Frankie’s also creates some of the best sandwiches in all of Australia, in addition to its inventive and interesting flavor combinations. Simply tortas and tacos are offered on the menu. The establishment is more reminiscent of a food truck than a café. In case you were unaware, a torta is a kind of Mexican sandwich; if you want to try something new, order a torta instead of a taco. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Inventive and interesting flavor combinations
  • Offers tortas (Mexican sandwiches)

Customer Testimonial:

“Great tacos and sandwiches. The food was awesome so worth a visit can’t wait to go back again.”

Ross Bartlett

9. King William Takeaway

Key ServicesCoffee and Tea, Cafe Food, Vegan Options, Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options
Address487 Flinders Ln, VIC 3000, Australia
Operating Hours11AM – 2PM Mondays – Fridays

If you’re looking for a place to spend your lunch hour in Australia’s central business district, go no further than The King William. This is because King William occupies such a prime site. In this little restaurant, where the decor makes you feel like you’re dining in someone’s living room, you can expect to find dishes with daring taste combinations and unusual ingredients. Take great care before spending $16 on one of them. They seem like they may be snatched up immediately, but that’s not the case. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Daring taste combinations and unusual ingredients
  • Prime location

Customer Testimonial:

“Really great sandwiches, would definitely recommend!!”

Luke Breasley

10. Aphro & Wolfe

Key ServicesCreative Toasties, Padre Coffee, Sandwich, Cafe Food, Breakfast, Home Delivery, Takeaway Available
Address566 Brunswick St, Fitzroy North VIC 3068, Australia
Phone+61 3 9489 8868
Operating Hours7:30AM – 3PM Daily
Key ServicesCreative Toasties, Padre Coffee, Sandwich, Cafe Food, Breakfast, Home Delivery, Takeaway Available

The Aphro & Wolfe café has been a staple of the Brunswick Street community since the early 1900s and is well-known for its delicious toasties and coffee. The building’s original layout has been carefully preserved, and it is filled to the brim with period antiques in order to pay homage to the area’s storied past. Avoid eating anything substantial in the hours before your visit, since the toasties will leave you feeling full for a long time. When we go out, we always have toasted cheese sandwiches with three different types of cheese and our own pesto. This is why they are one of the finest sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

Key Differentiators:

  • Toasties and coffee
  • Original layout and period antiques

Customer Testimonial:

“This place is awesome. The coffee is excellent, the toasties are delicious (my fave is the chicken) and the staff are so lovely. So lucky to have in my neighbourhood :)”

Sally Tyrell

Sandwich Shop Sydney

Overall, despite their popularity, amazing sandwich food businesses are designed to be easy to discover. They should have avenues for clients to contact them and conduct lucrative transactions. Sandwich shop proprietors are expected to be experts in their field, not just someone who have identified a potential business opportunity. We hope this information helps you choose the top sandwich shop Sydney has to offer.

If you’re looking for more recommendations, you can check out our other posts below:

Rachel Tan - FunEmpire

Article by

Rachel Tan is the editor at FunEmpire Media Australia. She has over 8 years of experience in the media industry discovering the best local businesses, places and things to do in Australia. From lifestyle, entertainment, food, travel, education and more, Rachel is a trusted source to curate the very best Australia has to offer.